MarsPolicy

House Minibus Bill Would Kill Mars Sample Return

NASA's Perseverance Mars rover took a selfie with several of the 10 sample tubes it deposited at a sample depot it is creating within an area of Jezero Crater nicknamed "Three Forks." The image was taken by the WATSON (Wide Angle Topographic Sensor for Operations and eNgineering) camera on the end of the rover's robotic arm on Jan. 22, 2023, the 684th Martian day, or sol, of the mission.
NASA’s Perseverance rover captured an image of itself and several sample tubes that await retrieval on the Martian surface. Image: NASA/JPL-Caltech/MSSS.

The dozens of tubes of Martian dust collected so far by the Perseverance rover are waiting for a ride that may never come. 

The House minibus appropriations bill governing NASA spending in FY2026, which was released this week, doesn’t mince words. “The agreement does not support the existing Mars Sample Return (MSR) program,” lawmakers wrote in an accompanying report explaining why lawmakers structured the bill the way they did. 

How we got here: The Perseverance rover landed on Mars in February 2021, gradually collecting at least 33 samples for later pick up and return. It was expected to be the first in a three-part journey to return the samples to Earth. 

However, runaway budgets that drove costs up to $11B forced the space agency to press pause on the mission in 2023, despite it being one of the top priorities in the last two planetary decadal surveys

In 2024, NASA asked industry for cheaper solutions, hoping its reliance on commercial tech for cargo, crew, and beyond could extend to the Red Planet. In January 2025, former NASA chief Bill Nelson laid out two options, both with a $7B+ price tag:

  • Using existing tech from JPL to bring the samples to Martian orbit, where they would be picked up by a European-built craft for the ride back to Earth.
  • Using a commercial heavy-lift lander to conduct the mission.

However, lawmakers have picked a third option: axing MSR entirely—at least for now. 

Hope, is that you? The report is clear that this is the end of MSR in its current form, but not the end for some of the tech that the program was working to develop. The spending bill—which still needs to pass Congress—would appropriate $110M for future Martian hardware, including for radar, landing, entry, and descent. That money could go to in-progress efforts for sample return, which are widely applicable to future exploration of Mars. 

Space Race: Martian Drift: If the age of Apollo marked the first space race, and the so-called Space Race 2.0 is the competition to build lasting infrastructure on the lunar surface, it stands to reason that Mars is the third chapter of the global space competition. Though Mars is very different from Earth, Space Race Versions 2 and 3 share one big similarity—China is hot on America’s heels. 

Beijing is working on its own plan to bring Martian samples back to Earth, dubbed Tianwen-3. The spacecraft is expected to launch in 2028, and to bring back at least 500 grams of Martian regolith by 2031, Chinese officials announced last year. 

“The mission will be a critical step in China’s planetary exploration. We hope to provide the international community with an unprecedented opportunity to understand Mars,” Hou Zengqian, chief scientist of the mission, said in a release.

Related Stories
Policy

Top 5 of 2025: Policy

The year in space policy ended with a bang, with the confirmation of NASA Administrator Jared Isaacman. 

Policy

Trump Signs Space Superiority Executive Order

President Donald Trump laid out a clear vision—and timeline—for America’s next steps in space in an executive order signed Thursday afternoon. 

Policy

Jared Isaacman Confirmed as NASA Administrator

At long last, NASA has a head again. That someone will be Jared Isaacman—now that the Senate has confirmed the billionaire private astronaut and entrepreneur—for whom the second time was the charm. The Senate voted 67–30 in favor of the appointment.

Policy

China Could Beat the US to the Moon, Experts Warn

Yesterday, four space industry and China experts appeared before the House Committee on Science, Space, and Technology’s Subcommittee on Space and Aeronautics testifying that if the US doesn’t step up, it risks ceding space superiority to China. That risk, according to witnesses, comes on all fronts—from the Moon and planetary science, to PNT systems and LEO security.