NASA Inspector General Highly Critical of SLS Spending

NASA’s Space Launch System (SLS)
Image via Aerojet Rocketdyne

NASA’s Office of Inspector General (OIG) issued a scathing report yesterday on the cost overruns in the engine and booster contracts under the Artemis SLS program. The report revealed $23.8B of total SLS expenses since 2012, resulting in a dizzying $4.2B cost per launch. 

Over the Moon: SLS is an expendable heavy-lift rocket designed to launch astronauts to the Moon on NASA’s Artemis missions. The NASA-funded launch vehicle but was set back by six years of delays and $6B of cost overruns on booster and RS-25 engine contracts alone.

In its no-holds-barred report, NASA’s watchdog office took aim at the SLS’s heritage design and cost-plus contracts. 

Heritage design: In an attempt to minimize expenses, in 2011, Congress directed NASA to design SLS with adapted Shuttle-era Northrop Grumman and Aerojet tech. NASA spent $581M to recertify and deliver 16 RS-25 engines, and so far has only received five for its investment.

Cost-plus contracts: NASA funds SLS largely through cost-plus contracts, which means the space agency maintains max control and ownership over the design but bears all cost overruns. So, when Northrup and Aerojet overspent, sometimes by twice the budget, NASA was forced to foot the bill.

In recent years, as the commercial space industry has matured, NASA has moved to awarding more fixed-price contracts—for example, through its Starship and Blue Moon lunar lander contracts. In its recommendations, OIG suggested exploring whether RS-25 Aerojet engine production could be adjusted to a fixed price to cap further agency risk. 

  • In a response to the OIG report, NASA pushed back against this suggestion, since the 11 engines in question are now nearly complete.

Other OIG criticism included inadequate management, procurement staffing shortages, poor negotiating, and millions of dollars of questionable contractor payments.

Related Stories

Clean Up In NSSL’s Lane 1

The US military’s scheme to diversify its stable of rocketmakers is running into a problem: None of them is likely to fly their rockets on time. 


Skyrora Partners with Spirit AeroSystems on Rocket Manufacturing

Skyrora, a UK-based launch startup, is aiming to keep its supply chain close to home as it gears up for its first orbital launch tests.


Payload Pioneers 2023: Stephanie Gavell

If you told Stephanie Gavell the problem wasn’t rocket science, she didn’t want to be a part of it. 


Kim Jong Un and Putin Meet at Spaceport, Discuss Rockets and Satellites

Kim Jong Un met with Russian president Vladimir Putin at Russia’s Vostochny Cosmodrome space center yesterday, marking the first meeting between the leaders in four years. Against the backdrop of the Russian launch facility, the pair discussed providing support for Kim’s satellite program and the possibility of sending the first North Korean to space. After […]