Why Private Companies Provide Better SSA Than The Pentagon

LeoLabs' newest space radar station in western Australia will feed SSA data to the US government.
LeoLabs’ space radar station in western Australia feeds SSA data to the US government. (Image:LeoLabs)

Rocket Lab ($RKLB) is expected to launch four Spire-built satellites on Wednesday for NorthStar Earth & Space that will collect space situational awareness data on objects in LEO. The constellation is a bet on a robust market for privately-collected space traffic info.

With the launch of the new TraCSS pathfinder last week, we’re closer than ever to seeing the government deploy commercial capabilities to fulfill the Department of Commerce’s mandate to create a public database of space activity. 

It’s not just to give DOD a rest from tracking the ever-increasing amount of stuff in orbit and focus on military objectives; it’s also that private SSA is more accurate than what the government is providing. Last year, the GAO found that the Space Force lacked a coherent plan to use commercial data and, as a result, used it sporadically.

It’s the maneuvers, stupid. One source of error (pdf) in current SSA is when spacecraft move for station-keeping purposes or to dodge a potential conjunction. Space Force trackers don’t receive information about maneuvers or may have trouble modeling them. 

Satellite operators have a solution—the Space Data Association, a clearinghouse for voluntary information created in 2009. During a Commerce Department trial in 2022 focused on GEO satellites, COMSPOC assessed its accuracy (pdf) was seven times better than the current standard thanks to its use of data from the association.

It’s the data. Military space trackers depend on the “Space Fence” radar built by Lockheed Martin ($LMT) (and, likely, some classified sensors as well). But commercial data sources, like LeoLabs’ six radar sites around the globe, Slingshot’s 150 optical sensors, or the on-orbit data collected by the new NorthStar constellation or Maxar’s Non-Earth Imaging sensors, among others, can provide more frequent observations and tracking than the DOD alone. 

And it’s the software. COMSPOC says its software was three times more accurate than legacy systems while tracking six MEO GPS satellites in 2022, even without user data. LeoLabs CEO Dan Ceperley said not to underestimate the complexities of managing the data flow from multiple sensors and collating it into timely and useful information.

Last year’s GAO report detailed how Guardians struggled to take advantage of commercial data “because the legacy systems were never designed for data sharing or connecting to a network.”

Related Stories

Bill Weber Steps Down as Firefly Aerospace CEO

Firefly has tapped board member Peter Schumacher as interim CEO while leadership kicks off a search process. 


The Growing Space Economy Is Doing Its Part To Fight Inflation

The space sector contributed $131B to American GDP in 2022, according to the most recent and precise analysis by the US government’s Bureau of Economic Analysis.


SIA Reports Record Growth for the Satellite Industry in 2023

The global space economy generated $400B of revenue last year, $285B of which ended up in the balance sheets of commercial satellite companies, according to the Satellite Industry Association’s State of the Satellite Industry Report.


Vast Inks Deal with The Exploration Company For Future Cargo Missions

The agreement opens the door for Europe to begin commercial and research-based missions in LEO.